GOTY 2019 & GOTD 2010-2019 - Full results on Page 1
  • regmcfly
    Show networks
    Twitter
    regmcfly
    Xbox
    regmcfly
    PSN
    regmcfly
    Steam
    martinhollis
    Wii
    something

    Send message
    regmcfly wrote:
    Let's begin again.

    So 2019 Is an absolute write off for me. I was lucky enough to go back to Japan, which was a world changing thing, but behind it all was the abortion we had at the start of the year. This time last year I was so excited about the prospects of a mini reg, and how that would affect our lives. Now, a year on, and an upsetting abortion later, my view of the world is very different. I'd hope that forum people with whom I'd previously had beef had noticed a change in my mentality. I basically can't even imagine how we all got here, and, to be really shitty, think we are all incredible. And we are even moreso for forming this forum, this gang or people who all meet to talk about how shit Death Stranding is. I very much value the contributions from all the people on here, and when I get a direct response to a post I have made, now value it moreso. Flora and I are okay and we will be stronger in the future. We are still keen to make a little one and will try to make that the case. 

    This all being said, this is the 'bad bum' that the Queen talked about, and I cannot wait until 2020 and a newfound sense of optimism instills itself in me. Blade Runner was rite. 

    What I posted yesterday was a rough set of games, so I will refine it, and there will be some changes. I do want to start by flagging up some great 'also-rans' however first. 

    Astral Chain

    In hindsight, it doesn't quite make the cut. But the elements are there - interesting and dynamic Platinum combat, mad anime world, an omnipresent dog mascot - these are the things that sweet reg dreams are made of. I can't quite justify the existence of it on my list because there's just not enough substance behind the absolute bubblegum pop exterior - which is no bad thing, fwiw. It's a showpiece and a showing off piece for Platinum, who continue to go from strength to strength and are becoming more and more confident in adding new types of gaming to their strong fighting repertoire. 


    Pixel Puzzle Collection

    Konami released a new franchise this year. With absolutely no fanfare, Pixel Puzzle Franchise dropped on phones. Within the title are over 500 picross puzzles that celebrate the company's history and reference key moments. It's playable offline and has no microtransactions - the absolute fuck. On subways around Tokyo this summer it was the go-to title. Addictive, clever, and well constructed. Get it.

    Control

    I really thought Control was going to do it for me. I thought the link of Alan Wake / Max Payne style gaming alongside something that was ripped right out of the X Files was going to be my goty. And for several hours it was absolutely great. The combat, ripping and tearing hunks of stuff at shadowy assassins whilst learning of some weird establishment, kept me going. But there was a point, possibly around 8 hours in, where it just felt like much-of-a-muchness to me, and I needed the next gameplay tweak to really keep me going. I'll go back and finish it at some point, but not this year, Remedy.

    Sayonara Wild Hearts

    Every Sunday morning, in bed, I grab my Switch and play 'Begin Again', aiming for the elusive Gold Rank. Flora makes fun of me for the routineness with which I engage in this activity, but fuck it. This is a pop album and a pop game - bite sized, accessible, and over very quickly. It helps that the Chvrches-esque style of music that is featured in the game is one to which I am partial, but it's just an overwhelming visual and aural package. Slight, yes, but isn't all good pop music?

    Death Stranding

    Look. I know. I get it. It's a bit of a bombscare, but there's something there, under all the bullshit, under all the fiddliness, that is absolutely fascinating. Kojima is nothing if not different, and I'm glad the game exists, even if I feel I'm going to have to plough my way through it with a helluva lot of effort. Those isolated moments where you walk and Low Roar come on - there's something incredibly hair-raising about them. It's a game to be admired, if not liked. 

    Right. So to it.

    5) Resident Evil 2 Remake
    Right at the time when we were in the worst of the above January stuff with regards to babies, one Sunday morning, I got a message from Elm that I had been gifted a copy of Resident Evil 2 on XBox. Being in a naturally fragile state I burst into tears and was obviously ridiculously grateful. January became a time when I retreated into the past, playing games that instilled nostalgia and reminded me of positive memories. Resident Evil 2 felt like the Bridge (Baby) for this (yes, I can't stop thinking about Death Stranding.) It has always been my favourite in the series, and on previous consoles, I could run it without even thinking. But this remake added so many interesting elements, not least making Mr. X into a real force of nature, something not even Nemesis managed. It's a fantastic version of how to update a game. I haven't put Link's Awakening on my list, even of to think about games, because it was so faithful, it felt like playing a 1993-ass game again. Resi 2 Remake showed how to take the mechanics of the past and bring them up to date. 

    4) Tetris 99 

    Where the Sam (Porter Bridges) Fuck did this come from? Announced and dropped with very little fanfare, this game has eaten up hours and hours (Cheryl Cole voice) of my life. It's such a stupid concept - Tetris meets Battle Royale - that it just works, and with the vagueries of the game upon launch it also became *coughs, moves notes* the Dark Souls of Tetris. Over the subsequent months since it has released it has dropped a £10 single player mode (DO IT) and multiple skins that can be earned through regular and mission play. To be brutally honest, had I not been utterly obsessed with clearing Mario World and Yoshi's Island to 100%, I would say this is the sole reason for having a Nintendo Online account, especially given Splatoon 2 wrapping up (pedants may note that Mario Maker 2 is not on a list here - it just wasn't enough to warrant it.) As a 'free' game, it's essential. 

    3)Fire Emblem - 3 Houses 

    As we worked through the year, we became more fixated on ensuring we had a good Summer holiday (we did - which helped) but I became fixated on the release of Fire Emblem. I became a relatively late convert to the series, only starting with Awakening, but I have really loved the emphasis on creating bonds (strands? no) between  characters and also the sheer brutality of the combat model. Whilst I still believe that Awakening (you never forget your first time) was the most pure / efficient of the ones I have played (Awakening / Fates / Echoes / This) the concept of basically being a lecturer in Harry Potter town was one that really engrossed me. I've played through it twice, and need to see the trifecta out, but I was shocked the second time about seeing the impact my taking time in lectures had on the durability of my gang. It's a damn fun game that looks at the same concept from three perspectives - objectively, subjectively and shit-headedly - and it's an absolute blast. 

    2) Hypnospace Outlaw

    1999 was a time, eh? I had a Geocities Adam and Joe fan page back then that I set up with my best mate. It was bright orange in the background and the text was in black, or more commonly, green. Those were great days. Hypnospace Outlaw allowed me to revel in that era, with music playing upon opening a page, dancing gifs, and lots of CAPITAL LETTERS. 
    It's one where, when you get below the surface, you see the actual people behind the webpages, their insecurities and their own, often selfish goals. The creator of the game has said that as long as the title is profitable, he will keep adding new websites to the 'internet' as it is, which just blows my mind. What will this title look like in 2020? 

    1) Apex Legends
    Dung-Dung-Dung-Duuunngg - that four chord landing theme has been my go-to-melody this year. Apex feels perfect. The mechanics of moving around, of sliding, of reloading, and generally working your way around the terrain are all remarkable, and speak to a team with considerable experience in dealing with first person mechanics. The squad options (although all you need is Pathfinder) are deep and varied, and Respawn even managed to expand upon these with their season 2 character launches. The game does not feel absolutely bogged down in the 'you must buy' mechanics that other games have, and every game feels 'fair'. It's my fault when I disengage from my team, it's their fault when they don't spot the shotgunner behind the door. It's a frankly incredibly distillation of the Battle Royale format, and to be given it for 'free' is even more ludicrous. I can't want to see where it goes next - Tomorrow is in their hands (I'm SORRY)

    Now to the others...


    Best sound Design
    1. Death Stranding - having Low Roar drop in at moments of calm is incredible. And in such a messy game, it's something to celebrate.
    2. Catherine Full Body - they've added Persona 5 tracks so that makes it good.
    3.Super Mario Maker 2 - the switching between worlds / styles never doesn't impress.

    Best visual Design
    1. Death Stranding - it's fucking gorgeous. It looks like you're in Iceland (the country) and I can't get over that.
    2. Resident Evil 2 Remake - more for what they did than what it is, I think it's an absolute stormer graphically. 
    3. Luigi's Mansion 3 - they spoke of wanting it to look like a Pixar movie, and it damn near gets close.

    Best writing
    1. The Outer Worlds - makes me laugh, makes me do a wry smile, makes me sad. This game is everything (flips bottle in slow motion)
    2. Control - for what I played there is something there, it feels delicately plotted and I appreciate the time the game takes to work its way into your system.
    3. Fire Emblem - Three Houses - 'Wow, you really saved my bacon'. 

    Best character
    1. Claude - Fae the Fire Emblems - He's the ultimate shithead, but also the guy in gaming you most want to go drinking with. 
    2. Zane - Outta Hypnospace Outlaw - conversely, Zane is the one guy you're never going chugging beers with. He may end up shooting you. 
    3.Mirage out of Apex - he's hot af. 

    Best ongoing game released before 2019 (anything that received further support, a major expansion/update etc. this year)
    1. Splatoon 2 
     
    Best game you played this year that didn't come out this year
    1. Super Mario World on the SNES Online Shit
     
    Game of the Decade
    1.Mass Effect 2
    2.Rock Band 2
    3. Dead Space 2 
    4. Hotline Miami
    5. Splatoon 2 
    6.Super Mario Maker 
    7. Yakuza 0
    8.Braid
    9. Breath of the Wild
    10. Super Mario Galaxy 2

    And now with my top 3 disappointing games.

    3. Gears 5 -
    So much hoo-ha had been made over "we're listening" and the promise of an open world, new modes, including a sort of escape mode of L4D, and then in the end it was... Gears. Granted, a very pretty, aurally impressive version of that game, but that. And the open world? A vast sea of nothingness. Gears needs a big break, a rethink, and time to let it fade away. A bit like Mass Effect.


    2. Afterparty-
    On paper, Christ. The developers of the bonkers "Oxenfree", a game where you go to hell and have to beat Satan in a drinking competition, drinks giving you speech perks? How could that not be incredible? Sadly it wasn't. A dull title with very little beyond that high concept pitch. I hope I don't burn out on this developer the same way every game post Bastion lowered my thoughts on Supergiant.

    1. The Outer Wilds -
    As I said, I'm as disappointed in myself as I am with anything else. The mechanics of flying, while not particularly my cup of tea, were fine. But the sheer sense of aimlessly exploring the universe and hoping I would stumble upon something to guide me did nothing to evoke, say, Breath of the Wild. The more hyperbolic the praise becomes around it, the more I think it's me that's broken. And that's disappointing.
  • regmcfly wrote:
    . I hope I don't burn out on this developer the same way every game post Bastion lowered my thoughts on Supergiant.

    Say it ain't so reg?

    What have you bounced off?

    Just transistor or have you tried and disliked em all?
    I'm still great and you still love it.
  • Nah reg - it’s not surprising that a game with so many moving parts will not necessarily work with everyone.
  • regmcfly
    Show networks
    Twitter
    regmcfly
    Xbox
    regmcfly
    PSN
    regmcfly
    Steam
    martinhollis
    Wii
    something

    Send message
    Facewon wrote:
    regmcfly wrote:
    . I hope I don't burn out on this developer the same way every game post Bastion lowered my thoughts on Supergiant.

    Say it ain't so reg?

    What have you bounced off?

    Just transistor or have you tried and disliked em all?

    I adore Bastion and would play it literally right now.
    Transistor was goodish but I didn't like the combat mechanics. Great Ost though.
    Pyre completely rubbed me the wrong way and I played a couple of hours then fucked it in the bin.

    Not played Hades yet, but what I've seen seems promising.

    On the other hand for Flora they've got better and better and she feels are the best developer getting her into genres she wouldn't normally play. She's excited for a roguelike run based game in Hades.
  • Fair. Hades is mint.

    Re pyre, I struggled too, and the mechanics were clever but never quite clicked completely, but man, that story ended up being amazing. I can still picture the final sections.

    A little like flora then, in that dialogue heavy stuff isn't usually my bag, but I was in with pyre.

    (probably helps it was the first thing I played on my laptop which was all shiny and new at the time.)
    I'm still great and you still love it.
  • regmcfly
    Show networks
    Twitter
    regmcfly
    Xbox
    regmcfly
    PSN
    regmcfly
    Steam
    martinhollis
    Wii
    something

    Send message
    New PC tomorrow let's get some Hades eh.
  • Hades is a gem, Pyre was a stinker
    Switch Friend Code: SW-5407-6034-9226

    PSN: derekg
  • Scanning through the thread, I don't think many people have bothered voting so far. If we don't get quite a lot more, especially for the decade, it's hardly going to represent the forum and its tastes.
  • I'm working off forum so i dont have to find wherever my post would be.
  • My post is more or less done. I’m still hopeful that I can play Astral Chain by month end.
    I am a FREE. I am not MAN. A NUMBER.
  • I can put up what I have so far and edit later.
    I am a FREE. I am not MAN. A NUMBER.
  • I'll be sorting mine out soon.
  • Mine is up. First page. Need to format and it’s also not final.
    I am a FREE. I am not MAN. A NUMBER.
  • regmcfly
    Show networks
    Twitter
    regmcfly
    Xbox
    regmcfly
    PSN
    regmcfly
    Steam
    martinhollis
    Wii
    something

    Send message
    Mine is final I'd say.
  • I forget if this has been asked already, but do early access releases count? Like stuff you can play through and enjoy, but isn't feature complete.
  • JonB wrote:
    Games released in early access this year also count.
  • Yeah, as long as it first went into ea in 2019, e.g Noita.

    I think one game that someone voted for that won't count is Hades. It went into ea in late 2018 and still hasn't had a full release.
  • Hmmm. 

    I’m thinking of a couple of replacements on my GotD list. Hmmmm.

    1-7 are locked in. 8-10 are swap-outtable.
    I am a FREE. I am not MAN. A NUMBER.
  • I hope one is The Swapper.
  • Shame about hades. That diminishes my list.

    I think, even on 3 hours or less play time I can safely add disco to the bottom of my yearly ones
    I'm still great and you still love it.
  • Facewon wrote:
    Facewon wrote:
    On phone and cutting and pasting, so will be messy for a bit.


    Game of the Year
    1. Ape Out
    2. Metro exodus
    3. Goose game
    4. Disco Elysium
    5.
     


    Best sound Design
    1. Ape Out
    2. Metro exodus
    3.

    Best visual Design
    1. Ape out
    2. Disco
    3. Metro

    Best writing
    1. Metro exodus.
    2. Disco
    3.

    Best character
    1. Ape
    2. Goose
    3. Atyem

    Best ongoing game released before 2019 (anything that received further support, a major expansion/update etc. this year)
    1. Destiny 2
     
    Best game you played this year that didn't come out this year
    1. Slay the spire*

    *see what I did there? ;)
     
    Game of the Decade

    Ok, in order.

    1 Slay the spire - 750 hrs and counting!
    2 Dark souls - 400 odd hours and fond memories of so much.
    3 Bfbc2 - still the goat for feeling like you're in a scripted epic single player mission with other people.
    4 Halo 5 - mp only, best since 3 and on dedicated servers
    5 Hollow knight - metriodvania done right
    6 Dirt Rally - best since cm2.0 on ps1. Pure.
    7 Hitman episodic - too much silly fun.
    8 Cities skylines - lovely relaxing times with the missus bossing me around.
    9 Mgs5 - best playground for all of kojimas toys.
    10 Metro 2033 - it's mabo, it's the vibe

    This becomes interesting to me again.

    Recent return to destiny 2 means that my default answer is actually a real answer now.

    It's doubly interesting to me, because of my own thinking around where destiny overall fits within the decade.

    For all the hours I pumped into d1, it was lean and flawed on release. And unlike halo, I had a lot of internal resentment to the hours I put in.

    D2 got off on the right foot, IMO. There were still issues, but the x amount of hours I pumped in at release were good fun, the pc version came at the right time, and my enjoyment of gaming generally on my laptop and 60fps probably helped.

    Even though I've paid for all content, my feeling around the game now, 5 years into the original 10 year plan, is completely different.

    The content is there, the variety is there, and while the grind is there too, the balance is right now, because as I've just been saying in the destiny thread, I'm doing some content from forsaken right now and I don't quite get the mechanics yet, I don't know what numberwang/gear it'll get me, and I frankly don't care.

    Just fucking inject the whole game world, gun play and action directly into my veins.

    (and I say this as someone who is 99.9% of the time soloing or playing with randoms)

    Was doing a mission in the dreaming city last night, and the level was just spectacular; the sheer size and verticality was huuuge. The number of enemies in play was immense, and yet within that, there was actually, much more so than d1, some of that halo DNA shining through around enemy attributes, and how they interact with player and other enemies. And also how much certain nasty enemies got you worried. (not quite like gold elites etc in halo 2, but also not just scary because bullet sponge.)

    (scorned and taken are fucking top tier enemies in d2. So much fun.)

    Jump on in folks, the water is beautiful.

    Still don't know about destiny in decade list. But my goty ranks done.
    I'm still great and you still love it.
  • I should get double points or some shit
  • Ooh, shout out to Dishonoured. That was 2012. Great game.
    I am a FREE. I am not MAN. A NUMBER.
  • -
    "Given how long it's taken for me to reconcile my nature, I can't figure I'd forgo it on your account."
  • +
    I am a FREE. I am not MAN. A NUMBER.
  • (Deadline this Friday? Many votes in yet?)
    I am a FREE. I am not MAN. A NUMBER.
  • Sorry, I did a new list but I realized I'd already done one. Was not minusing your comment!
    "Given how long it's taken for me to reconcile my nature, I can't figure I'd forgo it on your account."
  • For those different categories; I'm guessing that apart from the few that state otherwise they are all for games released in this year? Just because I've probably only played like two games released this year, and I'd quite like to fill some of those out for games this decade. I've been enjoying thinking about GotD because I generally don't get to participate in GotY discussions, I can never afford more than a couple of new titles in a year really, so I tend to get things a year or two or three later. I can put my GotD category picks in seperate formatting or in a spoiler tag or whatever so as not to confuse things, keeping JonB's job of counting easy.
  • It's all for GOTY except the top 10 for GOTD.

    I suppose I should start going through the thread this week and seeing what's what.
  • I will update mine last minute. It’s on first page. Need to format.
    I am a FREE. I am not MAN. A NUMBER.

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!