Just so everyone is aware, tomorrow we are asking you for rankings of Mainline Halos. This means everything from Halo 1-6 and also including Reach and ODST. The Wars series does not count here. I'm really genuinely interested to see what people think, as someone kind of cautiously optimistic for the new one.
I’ve done my tier list of Halo campaigns before. Halos as a complete package I don’t think I’ve really considered.
Probably something like:
S tier: CE and 3. 3 didn’t make it to S on my campaign list, but when the multi and forge are taken into account, it does rise up the rankings.
A tier: ODST, 4. Two solid campaigns, ODST’s probably being a bit better than 4’s, but 4 having the superior multi, eventually.
B tier: Reach, 2. Both flawed in their own ways. I still contend that 2 has the worst campaign in the whole of Halo, at least on Legendary (aka: the only way to play), but the multi was pretty damn good. Reach had an okay campaign and an okay multi, also eventually.
C tier: 5, although that may be down to the fact that I never really bothered with the multi, by all accounts it was very good, but I can only go on the campaign, which wasn’t great.
Honestly, I'm not sure how I'd rank halo. I don't mp so it's all about the sp for me.
I played through 4, 5 and 1 over the last year and I'd probably take rate them as 1 being tops, 5 being solid and 4 being a bit slow. Currently playing 2 and while my memory of it was merely ok, I've actually enjoyed it a lot even if it is a bit all over the shop.
I've found memories of 3 and reach but never got on with odst.
I’ve only played 1 and 2 and both weren’t really for me. I’m really intrigued by the new one though but apparently I can’t vote for number 6 yet so my list is;
4
2
Lost Legacy
1
3
Which is for the Uncharteds, which i have played. I can do Fargo series next if you’d like.