Kill a load of guys just doing their job either side of a cutscene and everything's cool, yet one of the gang kills a guy who definitely needs a good killing only to draw condemnation from the other mass murderers, fresh blood still spattered on their faces. Odd.

The plot armour is strong with certain antagonists too, they disappear as soon as the cutscene ends and before a shot is fired.

The sheer number of baddies you kill was a problem for me early doors. Strawberry in particular stood out as a ridiculous number of dead bodies, most of them weren't even lawmen, just to rescue that dick Micah. This is a thing in the Tomb Raiders and Uncharteds too, I'd definitely prefer fewer, harder hitting enemies where positioning, tactics and making shots count is more of a thing. As it is you can wander out into the middle of a gunfight with ten enemies and down them easily. Not that that can't be fun, but every mission?

stable hand. I mean, we only had to nick some horses, couldn't we do that at night when there's no one there? Or incapacitate him instead of killing him? Where are my options Rockstar? I thought they were going to make a thing of the issuing orders, planning heists etc. but that turned out to be a short lived thing. Can't remember the last time I could do that on a mission.

Same goes for the crop burning bit, the poor guard doesn't need to die does he? Come to think of it I didn't try tying him up, so maybe that one's on me, but I've a feeling it's not an option.