monkey wrote:To clarify what I meant, if she was brought back, unrepentant, and allowed to walk the streets, would everyone be alright with that?
RedDave2 wrote:monkey wrote:To clarify what I meant, if she was brought back, unrepentant, and allowed to walk the streets, would everyone be alright with that?
I think its more the UK washing its hands of a teenager who, yes, may be a bad one but she is young enough to not so much be given a second chance but the chance to be rehabilitated so that she may take advantage of a second chance if it becomes available.
Key thing is the 15 years of age.
Wouldn’t that be a very shaky case though? Given the age she fell into that world. Given the (probable) difficulty in getting evidence about her crimes from inside a defunct terrorist caliphate. I don’t know enough about it.Diluted Dante wrote:monkey wrote:To clarify what I meant, if she was brought back, unrepentant, and allowed to walk the streets, would everyone be alright with that?
She's accepted that returning to the UK opens her up to prosecution.
Lord_Griff wrote:It is an interesting question. Those that relinquish their membership of a society, should they be allowed back in. To an extent prison is a temporary removal from society. Should we ask for Abu Hamza back?
Funkstain wrote:As I say above this is nothing like Hamza. But I do believe in rehab (otherwise fuck it let's just murder them) and second chances. I think it's unlikely Hamza is showing anything that indicates he's ready to be re-integrated into "normal" society so he can rot wherever he's ended up.It is an interesting question. Those that relinquish their membership of a society, should they be allowed back in. To an extent prison is a temporary removal from society. Should we ask for Abu Hamza back?
Yossarian wrote:To be clear, that’s not just in your opinion, it’s illegal under something or other to revoke citizenship and leave someone stateless. If she couldn’t claim Bangladeshi citizenship, then revoking her British citizenship wouldn’t have been an option.
Yossarian wrote:Yep. Pretty much seems to be a judgment based on politics rather than anything else.
mistercrayon wrote:I’ll just stfu then
Lord_Griff wrote:Should we ask for Abu Hamza back?
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!